For P&C insurers
Your claims AI is only as good as the data at first notice.
Carriers are funding FNOL triage, claims document intelligence and fraud models. Most fail on intake data, policy history and claim keys that don't line up. In six weeks we profile the systems your use case depends on, grade each one, and give you a written verdict: go, fix then go, or no-go.
Already talking to an FNOL or claims-AI vendor? We grade your data before their SOW is signed.
- 6 weeks from data access
- From $75K, fixed fee
- Profiled, not surveyed
How It Fails
60% of P&C insurers are stuck in AI pilot mode. Here's how it happens.
Source: Capgemini, World Property and Casualty Insurance Report 2026. The pilot below is illustrative.
FNOL triage model · accuracy · illustrative
Week 8
The demo wins.
Trained on a curated set of historical claims, cleaned by hand, the FNOL triage model scores 92% in the steering committee demo. Funding approved.
Week 12
Production data arrives.
Real first notices start flowing: call-center notes typed under pressure, web forms with free-text loss descriptions, scanned PDFs from agents.
Week 19
Accuracy collapses.
The model never sees the structured loss details it was trained on. Accuracy slides to 58%. Adjusters stop trusting the scores and route claims by hand.
Week 26
Quietly shelved.
Nobody agrees why it failed, so the next budget cycle funds a different vendor. The same data is waiting for them.
Why: The Verdict finds the gap before the build starts, not after go-live.
Use Cases We Grade Against
Every grade is weighted to the use case you're delivering.
Why: A D on a system your use case never touches can wait. An F on the one it depends on can't.
What We Grade
The systems usually in scope.
Scoped by 5, 10 or 15 source systems: the ones your use case reads from, not the whole estate.
FNOL intake
Where triage decides, often on free text and scanned PDFs
Claims system
The labels a model learns from, and how they change
Policy admin
Coverage as it stood on the date of loss
Billing
Payment history that feeds fraud and retention models
Data warehouse
Where lineage is usually lost
Document stores
Adjuster notes and correspondence a model can't yet read
| System | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ClaimsCore | B | D | D | B | D |
| PolicyCore | D | D | D | C | D |
| FNOL Intake | C | F | D | C | F |
| ACORD Gateway | B | D | C | B | C |
| EDW | C | C | D | B | C |
This is where an FNOL triage pilot dies.
When the examiner asks where every input came from.
The NAIC Model Bulletin expects insurers to govern the data behind their AI systems. The lineage and documentation grades tell you whether you can answer today. They help you answer the examiner; they don't certify compliance.
See What You'd Get
A full sample read-out for a fictional P&C carrier.
Illustrative, not a client result.
Field Notes


